WonderSage

Deconstruct the Shoulds Ruling Your Life to Reclaim Your Authenticity

April 5, 2025 4 min read

The Invisible Weight of "Shoulds"

Do you ever feel like you're following a script you didn't write? A persistent whisper suggests you should pursue a certain career, maintain specific relationships, look a particular way, or even feel certain emotions. These pervasive "shoulds" – a blend of societal expectations, family legacies, cultural norms, and internalized pressures – can quietly dictate our choices, often leading us away from the life we genuinely desire. Living under the weight of these expectations can feel suffocating, breeding anxiety and dissatisfaction. But there's a path back to yourself, one that involves carefully dismantling these "shoulds" to reclaim your authentic way of being.

What Exactly Are These "Shoulds"?

"Shoulds" are the unwritten rules and expectations we absorb about how life is supposed to be lived. They manifest in countless ways:

  • Career: "I should climb the corporate ladder," or "I should choose a stable, high-paying job, even if it doesn't excite me."
  • Relationships: "I should be married by a certain age," "I should always put others' needs first," or "I should maintain relationships even if they are draining."
  • Lifestyle: "I should own a home," "I should constantly strive for more," "I should look perfect online," or "I should follow the latest wellness trends."
  • Personal Habits: "I should be more outgoing," "I should wake up earlier," or "I should feel grateful all the time."

These beliefs often operate beneath our conscious awareness, shaping our decisions and self-judgments without scrutiny.

Unmasking the Origins

These powerful directives rarely originate purely from within. They are often inherited or absorbed from:

  • Family: Explicit and implicit messages learned during upbringing.
  • Culture: Shared societal beliefs about success, happiness, and duty.
  • Social Media: Curated images of idealized lives create comparison and pressure.
  • Peers: The desire to fit in and gain approval.
  • Internalized Beliefs: Past experiences and self-criticism solidifying into rigid rules. Recognizing these sources is the first step in loosening their grip. Many "shoulds" are simply limiting beliefs we've adopted unconsciously.

The High Cost of Living by External Rules

Constantly striving to meet external or outdated internal "shoulds" takes a significant toll. It can lead to:

  • Anxiety: Worrying about judgment or falling short of expectations.
  • Dissatisfaction: A persistent feeling that something is missing, even when achieving conventional success.
  • Resentment: Towards others or oneself for choices made under pressure.
  • Burnout: Exhaustion from trying to maintain an inauthentic facade or meet impossible standards.
  • Lack of Fulfillment: A disconnection from genuine passions and joys.

As Brené Brown's research highlights, authenticity requires vulnerability and the courage to let go of who we think we should be to embrace who we are.

Becoming Your Own Detective: Question Your "Shoulds"

To break free, start questioning these ingrained beliefs. When a "should" arises, pause and ask:

  1. Where did this belief come from? (Family, media, culture, myself?)
  2. Does this genuinely align with my current values and desires? (Not my past self, or someone else's expectations).
  3. Is this belief still serving me, or is it holding me back?
  4. What am I afraid will happen if I don't follow this "should"? (Judgment, failure, disappointing others?) Acknowledge the fear.
  5. What would I truly prefer to do or believe instead?

This critical examination begins to separate external noise from your inner truth.

Realigning with Your Inner Compass: Values

Your core values are your personal navigational tool. When you're clear on what truly matters to you – principles like creativity, connection, freedom, security, compassion, or growth – you have a powerful filter for decision-making. Choices aligned with your values feel right, even if they challenge external "shoulds." Identifying what truly matters is fundamental; you can explore practical ways to uncover your true values and live an authentic life as a starting point. As Mark Manson suggests, choosing your values also means choosing what struggles you're willing to endure for the sake of those values, which is far more empowering than struggling against unwanted "shoulds."

Protecting Your Path: Boundaries and Experimentation

Living authentically requires defending your choices and exploring what feels right:

  • Set Boundaries: Authenticity often means disappointing others who hold different expectations. Protecting your time, energy, and choices requires clear boundaries. This often involves learning how to protect your energy and choices, essentially mastering the art of 'no' when necessary, to preserve your alignment.
  • Embrace Experimentation: Stepping outside your "should"-defined comfort zone can feel risky. Start small. Try a new hobby, express a different opinion, change a routine. Treat these as experiments to gather data on what genuinely resonates with you, not what you think should. Discomfort is often a sign of growth, not failure.

The Ongoing Journey to Authenticity

Deconstructing the "shoulds" is not a one-time fix but an ongoing practice of self-awareness, courage, and conscious choice. It's about consistently checking in with yourself, questioning external pressures, and bravely aligning your life with your own internal compass. By doing so, you move away from a life dictated by expectations and towards one defined by genuine fulfillment and authenticity.

Feeling overwhelmed by the "shoulds" in your life? WonderSage can help you clarify your values, identify your unique path, and create a personalized self-help book that guides you toward a more authentic and fulfilling life.

Ready for personalized guidance?

Get a self-help book written specifically for your unique situation, challenges, and aspirations.